Google’s Gemini Olympics Commercial – Double-plus Ungood

If you haven’t seen Google’s Gemini commercial yet here’s what’s going on.

Google has made an advertisement that it’s playing during the Olympics for its Gemini AI. In the advertisement a father wants to help his daughter write a letter to an athlete. So he uses Gemini…

“Help my daughter write a letter telling Sydney how inspiring she is and be sure to mention that my daughter plans on breaking her world record one day. (She says sorry, not sorry.)”

Wait what?

Who on earth would take something as personal as writing a fan letter and have an AI do it for them?

It’s not a marketing email!

Leave it to Google to use an advertisement showing what is basically a socially inappropriate use of AI as its key Olympics advertisement.

How does ChatGPT feel about people writing fan letters with AI?

The appropriateness of AI writing fan letters depends on several factors and perspectives:

Authenticity

Fan letters are typically valued for their personal touch and genuine expression of admiration. An AI-generated letter might lack the authenticity and emotional depth that a human-written letter can provide.

Intention

If the purpose of the fan letter is to express genuine admiration and connect with the recipient on a personal level, a human-written letter is usually more appropriate. However, if the AI is used to assist in drafting a letter that a human then personalizes, it could be seen as a helpful tool rather than a replacement.

Consent

The recipient’s perspective is important. Some people might appreciate the effort and creativity behind an AI-generated letter, while others might feel it is impersonal or insincere.

Ethics

Using AI to write fan letters without disclosing that they were AI-generated can be considered deceptive. Transparency about the use of AI is crucial in maintaining ethical standards.

Use Cases

There might be scenarios where AI-generated content is appropriate, such as helping individuals who have difficulty expressing themselves in writing. In such cases, AI can serve as a supportive tool to convey their thoughts and feelings.

Personal Connection

A fan letter is often a way for a fan to feel a personal connection with their favorite person. Writing the letter oneself can enhance that sense of connection and satisfaction.

In summary, while AI can assist in drafting fan letters, the appropriateness of fully relying on AI for this purpose varies depending on the context, intention, and ethical considerations. Human input and personalization are key to maintaining the genuine and heartfelt nature of fan letters.